Skip to main content

The Hidden Risks of Promissory Notes: What Every Investor Should Know

The Hidden Risks of Promissory Notes: What Every Investor Should Know

Promissory notes can seem like a straightforward and attractive alternative to traditional investments like stocks and bonds. However, they are not without significant risks, and scams involving promissory notes have defrauded investors of hundreds of millions of dollars.

While some promissory notes are legitimate investments, many that are widely sold to individual investors are fraudulent. These fraudulent schemes often promise high or guaranteed interest rates, making them particularly appealing. They may claim to be secured by various business ventures, such as real estate or startups, but these claims are often unfounded. It’s crucial to understand the investment you’re considering and be aware of the warning signs that could indicate a scam.

What’s a Promissory Note?

A promissory note is a form of debt that companies and individuals use to raise money, similar to loans. The issuer promises to repay the buyer’s funds (principal) and make fixed interest payments in exchange for borrowing the money. These notes have set terms, or repayment periods, ranging from a few months to several years.

Even legitimate promissory notes carry risks. Competition, poor management, or adverse market conditions can affect the issuer’s ability to fulfill its promise to pay interest and return the principal to note buyers.

The Problem with Promissory Notes

Fraudulent promissory note schemes are a significant issue. These programs often promise very high or guaranteed returns, claim to be backed by collateral, or make other appealing but false claims. Such schemes frequently target seniors or other vulnerable investors, exploiting their retirement savings or existing lower-risk investments.

Additionally, promissory notes are usually securities and must be registered with the SEC or the state in which they’re sold unless they have a specific exemption from registration. If a note isn’t registered, it can only be sold to certain individuals who meet specific net worth and income limitations, making it harder to find information on the issuer and the note. Moreover, individuals might sell these notes without the required securities registrations, or even without their firms’ knowledge or approval.

Protecting Yourself from Fraud

If you’re considering investing in a promissory note, follow these tips to protect yourself:

  1. Ask Questions: Inquire about the specifics of what will happen with your money during the note’s term and how it will generate the promised return. Ask how many other investors have been approached and how many have invested. If you don’t get satisfactory answers, walk away.
  2. Beware of Pushy Sales Tactics: No reputable investment professional should push you to make an immediate decision. Be cautious of claims that the investment is limited to a few investors or is “private” to create urgency and exclusivity.
  3. Check and Double-Check: Use the SEC’s EDGAR Database to check if the notes are registered. Verify with your state securities regulators if the investment and salesperson comply with your state’s laws. Use FINRA BrokerCheck to see if the investment professional is registered or has a disciplinary history. Check the Better Business Bureau for complaints against the issuing company.
  4. Know Your Seller: Ensure the note is being sold through the investment professional’s firm. If not, it’s being “sold away,” and you may miss important protections. Watch for red flags like personal email addresses, unfamiliar letterheads, or printouts from home computers. Verify any doubts by contacting the firm directly.
  5. Don’t Trust Guaranteed Returns: Salespeople cannot guarantee a specific return. Even if the note has a fixed interest rate, it might not pay that amount or return your principal. Be skeptical of claims that the notes are insured or secured by collateral unless you can verify these claims.
  6. Consider the Market: Be wary of promissory notes offering high returns, especially when market rates are lower. High potential returns come with higher risks. In high-interest-rate environments, sellers might use more creative pitches to attract investors.
  7. Understand Commissions: Ask about the salesperson’s compensation and where it’s disclosed to you as an investor. Promissory notes often offer higher commissions, creating conflicts of interest. Verify if the seller has any ownership interest or other incentives.

By staying informed and vigilant, you can protect yourself from fraudulent promissory note schemes and make more secure investment decisions.