Promissory Note Defense — Securities Industry Attorney – Bakhtiari & Harrison
How promissory notes work in the securities industry
When a financial professional joins a new broker-dealer, the firm typically provides an upfront loan as an incentive — often called a “forgivable loan,” “transition package,” or “signing bonus.” The loan is structured as a promissory note and is forgiven ratably over a period of years (typically five to ten) as long as the financial professional remains with the firm and meets production requirements. If the financial professional leaves — whether voluntarily or through termination — before the note is fully forgiven, the outstanding balance becomes immediately due.
Firms pursue promissory note repayment aggressively through FINRA arbitration, which is the required forum under most industry employment agreements. These claims are typically straightforward on their face — the financial professional signed a note, left before it was forgiven, and owes the outstanding balance. The firm’s apparent advantage is significant: they have the contract, they have the money, and they have institutional legal resources. Bakhtiari & Harrison’s role is to level that playing field.
The counterclaim strategy — turning defense into offense
The most important thing a financial professional facing a promissory note claim must understand is that these proceedings are not simply about defending the note. They are an opportunity to assert affirmative claims against the firm — and a strong counterclaim posture frequently produces outcomes that are far more favorable than pure defense.
Common counterclaims in promissory note proceedings include:
- Withheld compensation: the firm withheld bonuses, deferred compensation, or production credits at the time of departure — amounts that offset some or all of the outstanding note balance.
- False inducement: the firm made promises during recruitment that were never kept — production guarantees, support commitments, platform promises, or compensation representations — that induced the financial professional to leave a prior position and accept the note.
- Wrongful termination: if the financial professional was terminated rather than departing voluntarily, counterclaims for wrongful termination and breach of employment contract may significantly change the damages picture.
- Protocol for Broker Recruiting violations: if the departure involved Protocol violations by the firm, those violations may be asserted as counterclaims.
- Constructive termination: if the firm created conditions designed to force a resignation — removing support, changing compensation structure, or reassigning accounts — a constructive termination counterclaim may be available.
David Harrison’s years as Morgan Stanley in-house counsel give him direct knowledge of how major brokerage firms evaluate their counterclaim exposure when they file promissory note claims — and how to use that exposure to achieve favorable resolutions.
Transition planning — before the note dispute arises
The best time to address promissory note exposure is before a firm transition — not after the arbitration claim is filed. Bakhtiari & Harrison provides transition counseling for financial professionals considering a move: reviewing the note terms, analyzing repayment exposure, evaluating available counterclaims, assessing Protocol compliance obligations, and modeling the net financial impact of different departure scenarios. This pre-transition analysis frequently identifies leverage that can be used in negotiating the terms of a departure — or in the arbitration if one follows.
The arbitration process for promissory note claims
Most promissory note claims are filed in FINRA arbitration by the broker-dealer against the departing financial professional. The financial professional is the respondent — which means they are defending the claim while simultaneously pursuing their counterclaims. Bakhtiari & Harrison manages the full FINRA arbitration process on behalf of the financial professional: filing the answer and counterclaims, conducting discovery, preparing the evidentiary record, and presenting at the hearing.
Frequently asked questions — promissory note defense
Do I have to repay the full promissory note balance if I leave my firm?
Not necessarily. The outstanding balance is the firm’s starting position — it is not necessarily the ending one. Counterclaims for withheld compensation, false inducement, wrongful termination, and other grounds can reduce or eliminate the net amount owed. In some cases, well-developed counterclaims result in the financial professional recovering money from the firm rather than paying the firm. Bakhtiari & Harrison evaluates the full financial picture — including counterclaim potential — in every initial consultation.
Can I assert counterclaims against my firm even if the promissory note arbitration has already been filed?
Yes. Counterclaims can be filed at any time before the arbitration hearing, subject to applicable deadlines. Acting promptly is important — the earlier counterclaims are asserted, the more time the firm has to evaluate their exposure and the more leverage the financial professional has in settlement negotiations. Contact Bakhtiari & Harrison immediately if you have received a promissory note arbitration claim.
My firm says I left “for cause” and the note is not forgivable — is that correct?
That depends on the specific note terms and the facts of the departure. Many promissory notes have provisions that accelerate repayment in the event of a termination for cause — but what constitutes “cause” under the note may be narrower than what the firm asserts. Bakhtiari & Harrison reviews the note terms and the facts of the departure to assess whether the firm’s characterization of the departure as “for cause” is legally sustainable.
I was recruited with promises that were never kept — does that affect the note?
Yes, potentially significantly. False inducement claims — where the firm made promises during recruitment that were never kept — can be asserted as counterclaims in the promissory note arbitration. Damages for false inducement can include the value of commissions, bonuses, and other benefits given up at the prior firm, which can offset or exceed the outstanding note balance. Preserve all evidence of recruitment promises — emails, offer letters, term sheets, and notes from conversations — as this evidence is critical to a false inducement counterclaim.
Contact a promissory note defense attorney — free consultation
Contact Bakhtiari & Harrison for a free, confidential consultation. Our FINRA attorneys review every potential matter at no charge.
Financial professional cases are handled on a flat fee or hourly basis. Initial consultations are free.
Call: (800) 382-7969 | Contact Us